MattH
I used the orange one on my last annual service. It’s night and day with the black one.
The orange has a nice spongy feel too it and seems to be holding up well after about 9 months.
I always find the black rubber ones so firm when new, to the point the PF doesn’t lock in at 90 degrees. Not that it really matters.
Either does the job though!
I forgot how good that grey looks on the machine too!