simonc hornbyben

Thanks gentlemen! That’s a lot of useful information to digest. I am going to have to digest and come back with more questions / clarifications. You are going to hate me for sure.

In summary, it is interesting and promising. Two different interesting approaches, which are expensive, keeps a centrally located installations and keep every thing local.

A few busy spring and summer seasons for sure - doors, windows, garden work, automation project plannings and home decorations (DIY painting). My hands are full for 3-4 years at least. I wonder, when I am going to find time to design and build my speakers!

    I must say that I’m disappointed by the pace at which home automation is evolving. I built what was considered at smart home over 20 years ago (Crestron AV distribution with some of the first HDTV devices on the market, alarm, lights and other controls over X10, IR receivers and serial interfaces). Looking at it recently, functionality and reliability are still iffy by my standards (at least based on what I read and on my experience with Zigbee devices. IP protocols only offer limited benefits over RS232 but many devices are buggy, poorly documented and with too many constraints). I can see the merit of some cheap and limited solutions (Zigbee using Ikea lights), but am not convinced by the more costly proprietary solutions I’ve seen or played with.

    LMSC No problem, always happy to give my perspective, but I fully recognise that what’s right for me may not be true for you.

    One day I am going to walk into a house and feel like Joe Biden, unable to turn the lights on, work the TV, boil a kettle etc…I will just be stuck sitting in a chair in the dark…not knowing the command to recline it!

    Giphy - Joe Biden GIF by GIPHY News

    I just Joe doesn’t get confused and shout Launch, when he means lunch, because his football (Alexa briefcase) could start WWW3

      DavecUK One day I am going to walk into a house and feel like Joe Biden, unable to turn the lights on, work the TV, boil a kettle etc…I will just be stuck sitting in a chair in the dark…n

      You will be alright as your set up allows manual on/off using the switches

        LMSC I was worried about a future where there are no more switches. Lot easier for builders not to put light switches etc in.

        • LMSC replied to this.

          DavecUK We as a community will be alright learning to cope up with changes, like we have done in the past!

          LMSC No worries. My electrician on the whole house rewire (as part of major renovation) quoted £10k for a whole house Loxone. I didn’t have the budget at the time, to do it in one go, so went slowly. Started on a Vera which was woefully under powered and support was poor before I moved to Indigo which is about as stable as it comes without custom hardware, and amazing support. It let me build slowly and add as I needed to without having to pay service calls. I also have full control on cloud or local control etc and the plugin community is well developed.

          The important thing is I didn’t want it to be a control your house from your phone setup, but a truly smart one, where things just happened for you, like lights automated, at night, but also day if it gets dark say due to a storm. Or heating is off during the day but if one of us works from home then that person’s study will have heating on during the day, and the kitchen etc. Not sure how much custom logic can be built into some of the custom hardware options.

          I also like being able to unlock my side gate with my voice to my watch whilst I have my hands full. That is useful.

          But its come at a cost of time and effort in setting it all up, both wiring and defining all the logic. There is virtually no code in my setup, although I could write python to control it if needed, but a lot of logic and rules / triggers through the application.

          It does however let me update hardware cheaply. I Tried some zigbee temperature sensors that didnt work out, but they were £10 a pop. The £15 upgrades work much better. I find zwave most reliable, but zigbee can be faster (zwave seems to queue one at a time) but when zwave didnt quite have the right hardware I can use zigbee, for instance with colour temperature changing LED strips, rather than RBG ones.

          Funnily enough there is an espresso thread on the home automation forum I use, where a lot of people started automating their espresso machines and moved on from there!

            simonc

            Thanks Mate! Very useful information from you and @hornbyben. A lot to digest, take notes for reference and come back here.

            £10K sounds about right. That would be the cost for the whole house wiring cum wifi Laxone combo for lights, switches, radiators and a few smart plugs. Curtains, multi-media (Laxone is not strong here), irrigation, camera, alarms, etc, the cost escalates.

            I don’t seem to find Radiator smart valves with Heatmiser.

            Btw, we have almost closed out the doors and windows contract. The local council isn’t very helpful with a few things we wanted to check. We need to read our contract for restrictive covenants, perhaps pay a bit to the council for a proper advice and go from there.

            The company that does new builds and existing dwellings instal did advise us we are ok to change the windows and doors like for like. A different coloured main door is something they feel it is better to check with the council as it is a deviation.

            Thx